Sujet: Mrdrunkenpony-Regenge story Jeu 12 Sep - 13:29
yo guys this is my new amv ... a fast one didnt have much time to do it yeah i know some flaws like pancrop or the lip flap but i think its pretty good considering my level but i could still make it reallly better so tell me what you think ;D
Messages : 7148 Date d'inscription : 28/10/2009 Age : 30 Localisation : BELGIQUE
Sujet: Re: Mrdrunkenpony-Regenge story Ven 13 Sep - 15:15
Hello,
There's a little progression but it's still not quite. First, there's a problem with your scene selection for the part at 0:22, you shouldn't have used these boring fights but rather somehow a presentation of the characters or something else but anyways not some bold gunfights like this. It doesn't fit the atmosphere of this part of the song.
And then there are some unexplainable long scenes, the one at 0:50 I really can't figure it out why you put it there since the lip synch is totally off. But what comes next is better, maybe it still lacks in impact but it's okay until 1:16. Voices, why not but the choice is really bad and why putting it at the beginning of the chorus like this, from this point it all feels like the chorus was just a background just to wait for another random voice. There's no rythm anymore and the end is just a fade.
So yeah well, the progression is just in some parts but the others still need a lot of work. Keep it up
Breaker Ambassadeur
Messages : 506 Date d'inscription : 31/03/2013 Age : 26 Localisation : Yorozuya
Sujet: Re: Mrdrunkenpony-Regenge story Ven 13 Sep - 20:23
Yo! So the beginning was pretty nice and 0:44-0:49 was pretty cool too IMO but the end kinda got out of hand.
Didn't really like the voice overs sorry =/ but i can see what you tried to do. Some of the cam movements were quite cool and some needed to be a little better. You should try to be more creative with your transitions
And like MDL says the rythm could be better. Listen to MDL he knows what's up On to the next !!! :P
Echotrooper Sora to Kasai
Messages : 10579 Date d'inscription : 05/04/2009 Age : 35 Localisation : The City
Sujet: Re: Mrdrunkenpony-Regenge story Sam 14 Sep - 10:32
Hey! I'm not a great fan of the voices on amv put it's just my opinion. About the rest of the amv, I agree with what MDL and Breaker said. Anyway, It's not that bad, but I think you could do way better on the next one!
Good luck!
DrunkenPony Roseau Fringant
Messages : 37 Date d'inscription : 22/05/2013
Sujet: Re: Mrdrunkenpony-Regenge story Sam 14 Sep - 14:45
thanks guys you are really helpfull ill try to take under consideration all the things you told ;D
General-Guy Suceur de nouilles
Messages : 86 Date d'inscription : 10/12/2012 Age : 35
Sujet: Re: Mrdrunkenpony-Regenge story Dim 22 Sep - 17:57
My final impression: I think the overall story flow lacked logic. Well, amvs are not always about having a coherent story. But the way I see it, you focused on some moment that seemed...quite logic for a clear story (with the first second and the moments with the girl, you would expect something more clear out of that in the end).
Beside this, original dub voice simply breaks your viewer bubble...and your own music, and rythm, and synch ; use with A LOT of moderation.